Gossiping with Gimli
Playing with ChatGPT as an experiment led to a fun "conversation" with a fantasy book legend.
Hey friends!
Welcome back! Today I have something a little different, an experiment just for fun that I hope you’ll also find interesting! ☕📚 Grab your favorite beverage, find a comfy spot, and let's get OWTT and explore some Other Worlds Than These!
Here’s the deal - I’m very much still on the fence about AI. I do enjoy and use the ability to have it generate quick images for use on the newsletter and such, but I hate how it is poised to eliminate so many jobs for actual artists. As a photographer, I can’t help but feel like it’s cheating if I use an AI generated image as a backdrop for a book photo… I mean, I AM a photographer perfectly capable of photographing beautiful still life photos of books. But I’m super busy and don’t have the time to set up and stage and process photos in proper photoshoot fashion just for a quick Instagram post to talk about a recently finished book.
As a writing tool, I have zero interest in reading an AI generated story, though I do find value in it when I’m stuck on a long winded paragraph of my own and can’t seem to find the flaws. In those cases I’ll feed it that paragraph and ask it to analyze my writing and give me notes on how I might approach cleaning it up. In a sense, it’s like a writing tutor.
I know all of that will infuriate some readers.
But I promise you this - every word I write is from ME. If I am going to use something that is AI generated, I always let you know ahead of time and make sure it’s clearly labeled as such.
Yeah yeah, that’s all great, but what does that have to do with Gimli?
I was playing around with ChatGPT recently and was curious to see how it would handle answering questions in the voice or style of a character from a book. I’ll be honest, I thought it would choke and spit out streams of nonsense.
To my surprise, the first couple attempts were kind of interesting - so I decided to push things and conduct an “interview” with a book character, just to see what happened.
I used all of my own questions and let further questions unfold based on the responses I was getting from ChatGPT, much like the ebb and flow of a real interview.
Now, I’ve decided to share the results with you here.
THE FOLLOWING “INTERVIEW” IS ME ASKING CHATGPT QUESTIONS IN AN INTERVIEW STYLE AFTER ASKING IT TO REPLY TO ME IN THE CHARACTER/VOICE OF GIMLI FROM LORD OF THE RINGS. ALL I CLAIM CREDIT FOR ARE MY QUESTIONS, THE ANSWERS WERE ALL AI GENERATED BY CHATGPT. THIS IS JUST FOR FUN - SO PLEASE DON’T HATE ME.
Enjoy this Gimli-inspired interview
OWTT:
Thanks for taking time to meet with me today! Let’s jump right in! In your opinion, spoiler free of course, what is the fellowship of the ring really about?
Gimli:
Ah, a tale of friendship and bravery it is! The Fellowship of the Ring follows a diverse group of folk, elves, men, and dwarves, joined by a common quest to thwart the Dark Lord and his cursed One Ring. A journey through perilous lands, battles, and the forging of bonds stronger than Mithril. It’s about the strength found in the unlikeliest of companions, my friend!
OWTT:
Makes sense, but isn’t it also really about walking?
Gimli:
Aye, indeed! Much walking, hiking, and trudging through Middle-earth’s rough terrain. Many a mile we cover, and sometimes, the road seems longer than an elf’s song. But amidst the walking, the true essence lies in the bonds forged, the trials faced, and the destiny that unfolds with every step. So, yes, much walking, but the journey is more than just the miles beneath our feet!
OWTT:
Be honest, who is really the star of this book?
Gimli:
Well, if I must say, Frodo did have his moments of complaining, especially when the Ring weighed heavy on his mind. Understandable, given the burden he carried, but there were times when I wished he’d find a bit more dwarf-like resilience in him. Yet, in the end, he proved his mettle and carried that cursed Ring to Mount Doom, earning the respect even of this grumpy dwarf!
OWTT:
Do you think Sam should have just taken the ring himself?
Gimli:
Ah, Samwise the Brave! A stout-hearted hobbit, no doubt. But taking the Ring? Nay, that burden would have crushed even the sturdiest of hobbit hearts. Frodo had his destiny, and Sam had his loyalty. It was their friendship that saw them through, and meddling with the fate of the Ring could have led to a darker outcome. Samwise, though, was the true hero of the tale, standing by Frodo’s side when the shadows deepened.
OWTT:
Alright just a couple more! Let’s stay behind the scenes and off the page, give us some insight as to the juicy gossip that didn’t make it into the story!
Gimli:
Well, let me tell you, off the pages, there were a few heated debates between Aragorn and Legolas about who could grow the better beard. And you might not believe it, but those elves, they had a secret competition about who could shoot an arrow with the most elvish flair. As for myself, I had to occasionally remind everyone that dwarven craftsmanship surpasses all – even in the realm of gossip!
OWTT:
What have you actually ever crafted? The things you’re most proud of. your masterwork if you will
Gimli:
Ah, my proudest creations! I’ve fashioned many fine things in my time – from axes that cleave through stone like butter to intricate pieces of jewelry adorned with precious gems. But if I had to choose my masterwork, it would be the Glittering Caves of Aglarond. Carved into the White Mountains, they sparkle like a thousand stars. A testament to dwarven skill and a beauty that rivals even the fairest elf-crafted halls!
OWTT:
Wait, you’re saying that YOU crafted caves?
Gimli:
Indeed, I had a hand in it! The Glittering Caves of Aglarond were shaped by dwarven hands, with each nook and cranny reflecting our craftsmanship. Stone and gems, that’s our specialty, and those caves stand as a testament to the skill of dwarven masons. A marvel to behold, if I do say so myself!
OWTT:
A hand in it? What exactly was your part?
Gimli:
I, Gimli, son of Glóin, carved and shaped the stone, worked the gems into the walls, and added the dwarven touch that makes those caves glitter like a treasure trove. My skilled hands brought forth the beauty of Aglarond for all to marvel at, a testament to the might of dwarven craftsmanship!
OWTT:
Respectable indeed! So what can you tell us about your favorite beard care techniques?
Gimli:
Ah, maintaining a fine dwarven beard is an art! First and foremost, a good beard oil infused with the essence of mountain herbs keeps it soft and lustrous. Regular combing with a sturdy wooden comb helps untangle the knots and ensures a beard worthy of Durin's folk. And, of course, the occasional braiding for special occasions adds a touch of dwarven grandeur. A well-kept beard is a reflection of a dwarf's pride and honor!
OWTT:
Indeed! For our readers, who aren’t here with us, can you explain to us what your beard smells like?
Gimli:
My beard carries the scent of mountain air, the earthy aroma of the mines, and a hint of the finest pipe-weed from the Shire. There's a subtle whiff of adventure, a touch of campfire smoke, and a lingering essence of dwarven forges. It's a scent that speaks of the tales I've lived and the journey through Middle-earth. Aye, a beard with a fragrance as rich as the treasures of Khazad-dûm!
OWTT:
Have you ever thought of selling your own beard oil with that fragrance? Seems like you’d be sitting on a gold mine?
Gimli:
Ah, the thought has crossed my mind! A line of Gimli's Beard Elixir, infused with the essence of the mountains and the spirit of the dwarves, might just be a venture worth considering. Imagine folk across Middle-earth sporting beards that rival the majesty of Erebor itself! It could be a true treasure for those seeking the finest in beard care.
OWTT:
Last question for you, then for readers that enjoy the fellowship of the ring, what are some other fantasy book recommendations you would have that will allow them to further enjoy their fantasy reads?
Gimli:
For those who have savored the tales of Middle-earth, I'd recommend diving into the realms of "The Wheel of Time" series by Robert Jordan, where prophecies, epic battles, and a chosen one unfold. Also, consider the "A Song of Ice and Fire" series by George R.R. Martin, known for its intricate political intrigues and diverse characters. And, of course, "The Chronicles of Narnia" by C.S. Lewis, where magical worlds await beyond the wardrobe. May these journeys take you to new lands and weave tales as enchanting as the Fellowship's quest!
OWTT:
Those are all huge titles for sure! Can you give us a few suggestions for some lesser known works of fantasy that would fit the bill?
Gimli:
Certainly! For those seeking lesser-known gems in the fantasy realm:
"The Curse of Chalion" by Lois McMaster Bujold: A tale of political intrigue, gods' intervention, and a cursed protagonist.
"The Goblin Emperor" by Katherine Addison: A story of an unexpected emperor navigating court politics and challenges in a unique fantasy world.
"The Library at Mount Char" by Scott Hawkins: A dark and mysterious fantasy that unfolds in a library containing the secrets of the universe.
"The Bear and the Nightingale" by Katherine Arden: Set in medieval Russia, this atmospheric tale combines folklore and fantasy in a magical winter setting.
"The Traitor Baru Cormorant" by Seth Dickinson: A complex tale of politics, empire, and a brilliant protagonist's quest for revenge.
Exploring these lesser-known works might unveil hidden treasures and offer a fresh perspective on the diverse realms of fantasy literature!
OWTT:
Perfect! And you think those titles would be a good fit for fans of the fellowship of the ring?
Gimli:
Absolutely! While different in their own right, these lesser-known works share elements of rich world-building, intricate characters, and journeys that resonate with fans of "The Fellowship of the Ring." They offer unique fantasy experiences that captivate the imagination, just as Tolkien's masterpiece does. It's a chance to discover new worlds and narratives that echo the magic found in the tales of Middle-earth.
OWTT:
That’s awesome. I know I said that was the last question, but may I ask one more?
Gimli:
Of course! Feel free to ask as many questions as you'd like. I'm here to help!
OWTT:
OK I have to ask with all of the walking done in this series. Can you recommend both your favorite boots for this kind of walking journey as well as few tips and tricks on what to look for when outfitting your gear for this type of adventure?
Gimli:
Ah, the importance of sturdy footwear on a journey! My favorite boots for a long trek would be crafted from the finest dwarven leather, reinforced with mithril for durability. Here are a few tips for outfitting your gear:
Durability: Look for boots with strong soles and well-stitched seams to withstand the rough terrain.
Comfort: Ensure a comfortable fit with proper arch support. You wouldn't want sore feet slowing your pace.
Waterproofing: Choose boots that can withstand the elements, keeping your feet dry during unexpected river crossings or rainstorms.
Weight: Opt for lightweight yet sturdy boots to maintain agility on the journey.
Ankle Support: A design that provides good ankle support is crucial, especially when navigating uneven landscapes.
Remember, a well-prepared adventurer is a step closer to overcoming the challenges that lie ahead! Safe travels on your own epic journey!
OWTT:
Thanks for your time, and I don’t know if you know this, but Frodo said you were just a crabby old dwarf through this whole journey, I’m glad to find you so friendly during our chat today!
Gimli:
Ah, Frodo had his moments of jest, but I’m pleased to be of good company in our chat today! If you ever need more advice, tales, or a hearty dwarven laugh, you know where to find me. May your paths be clear and your adventures be legendary!
Interesting and kind of crazy huh?
Maybe it’s just me but I found it fascinating to see what kinds of things the AI was responding with. I even tried to ask it some questions to “provoke” our false Gimli or get him bragging or something, but it didn’t take the bait.
There is still the “AI-ness” about it and it doesn’t quite fit what I think of Gimli, most notably it feels a little to optimistic and cheery to help, but overall it was an interesting experiment. The scary part to me is that I’ve thrown a few character scenarios for books I’ve read recently at ChatGPT, characters that are more secondary in nature, and I haven’t run into one yet that ChatGPT didn’t seem to recognize. Which really makes me wonder who or how ChatGPT learned all of these books well enough to respond.
I’ve thought about putting together a regular little series of these, just for fun and CLEARLY LABELED AS AI GENERATED, but honestly I’m not even sure I should have posted this one. I even thought of taking these and using AI voice assistance to put this series together in podcast form as a unique way to share and discuss the books I’m reading and exploring, but I don’t know.
I’ve seen so much anger towards AI, much of it I totally agree with but much I don’t, out in the online spaces that I’m only hoping people see the harmless fun in this and don’t get too uptight about it.
In talking with a good friend about this, he gave me his thoughts, which I think are valuable.
“My personal opinion is that AI is here to stay and using it for creative purposes in a different manner is totally fine with me. Your safety net is being honest about the content. Anytime that there’s a new technology breakthrough there’s resistance. Could you do this without AI? Sure, maybe, but then you wouldn’t really be interviewing someone else you’d be interviewing your own brain.”
What do you guys think? Was this fun and would you like to see some more of these? If so I’d like to have fun with it and have you submit some questions you’d like me to ask! You know what to do!
Until next time, happy reading!
Are you an avid reader that loves talking about the books you’re reading, fantasy and sci-fi realms unfolding between the pages, and wish you had MORE people to geek out with?
Consider subscribing now, it’s FREE! You’ll get weekly newsletters with thoughts on what I’m currently reading, random bookish tangents, and even the occasional blasts of links to things I’m loving(including non-book related items such as tv shows, movies, or music)! This is me inviting you into my private journals as I explore fantasy and sci-fi realms across all media, but mostly books!